Welcome to Dugout Pizza
At Dugout Pizza, nestled in Caledonia, Ohio, pizza isn't just a meal; it's a community experience. This locally owned gem serves an array of mouthwatering pizzas, known for their fresh toppings and exceptionally addictive sauce. Customers rave about the homemade breadsticks paired with jalapeño cheese sauce and cherished family favorites, like the classic cheese and pepperoni pie. For many, Dugout Pizza evokes nostalgia, with long-time patrons swearing by their delicious foldovers and garlic butter pizzas. Whether you're picking up for a cozy family night or enjoying a slice with friends, Dugout Pizza offers a heartfelt taste of home that keeps everyone coming back for more.
Dugout Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Wow! A pizza place worth making a drive for. Tucked into the town of Caledonia off the outskirts of Marion and 23 is a fantastic and locally owned. Some of the best pizza, amazing and fresh toppings, coupled with an addictive sauce. Thank you Dugout!
So lucky to have this hometown pizza joint. Excellent food. Our family favorites are homemade bread sticks with jalepeno cheese sauce and large pizza with cheese, pepperoni, mild peppers and mushrooms. Yummy!
We've ordered pizza, foldover's, and salads from Dugout for many years now and it's always very good. Whenever my son visits from California, he insists on ordering from Dugout at least once before he goes back.
I've been getting Dugout Pizza since I was still in school and it is STILL my favorite place to get pizza. If you get a chance try the pizza rolls and garlic butter pizza! We LOVE it!
Great pizza and breadsticks! Can't go wrong with this on a Friday night! However pickup is usually faster than delivery but delivery is much more convenient :)
Delicious! The best pizza in the county for sure. I'd love to say the state but people may think I'm exaggerating. The pizza, salads and subs cannot be beat. Tons of topping options and up to 17" pizza. We ordered 5x17", 3 salads and breadsticks for a family get together and they had it done in less than an hour. Prices are great too!
Location
-
116 E Marion Caledonia, OH 43314 United States Hotline: (419) 845-2810
Welcome to the delightful world of Dugout Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the charming town of Caledonia, Ohio. Located conveniently at 116 E Marion, this locally-owned pizzeria has become a community favorite, drawing in pizza enthusiasts from near and far. The warm and welcoming atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for family gatherings or a cozy night in with friends.
What makes Dugout Pizza truly special? It's the exceptional quality of ingredients combined with a passion for crafting delicious pies. The standout feature here is undoubtedly the addictive sauce that customers rave about, paired perfectly with fresh, vibrant toppings that elevate every bite. From classic pepperoni to creative combinations, there’s something to please every palate.
- Homemade Breadsticks: A local favorite, the breadsticks come with a mouthwatering jalapeño cheese sauce, perfect for sharing or enjoying solo.
- Pizza Rolls: These delightful bites are a must-try; stuffed with fresh ingredients and served with their signature garlic butter pizza for an extra kick.
- Foldovers & Salads: Beyond pizza, customers appreciate the variety of foldovers and fresh salads, making it easy to create a complete meal.
Customers like Michael G. have gone as far as to say that it's worth the drive to enjoy Dugout Pizza’s offerings, while Emily O. highlights the large pizza with cheese, pepperoni, mild peppers, and mushrooms as a family favorite. The reviews consistently point to a deep-rooted love for the quality and consistency of dishes — whether it's a Friday night pizza order or a nostalgic childhood indulgence, Dugout Pizza leaves a lasting impression.
As the saying goes, “Once you try it, you’ll always come back.” That sentiment rings true for many, including Lewis G., who shares that his son insists on ordering from Dugout whenever he visits from California. This speaks volumes about the relentless dedication to delivering top-notch pizza that brings smiles to faces.
In summary, if you find yourself in Caledonia, don’t miss out on the chance to experience Dugout Pizza. With exceptional flavors, highly praised service, and a true hometown vibe, you’ll discover why this pizzeria has captured the hearts of its loyal patrons. Treat yourself to this culinary delight — it promises an experience that's both satisfying and unforgettable.
